I
watched this again last night. Its brooding description of an
alternative America echoes the feel of the Trump rallies and the
nature of the American Election process. In the film it is asked What
happened to the American Dream. Rorschach replies “ Here it is2
“look at it” I have included at the vignettes from the film.
This graphic novel is uncomfortable to watch and yet shows the value
of this genre to serious academic discourse.
The
graphic novel genre is still in most places perceived as being far
from the realm of serious literature. In a way graphic novels such as
More and Gibbons “Watchmen” have allowed people like myself who
read serious literature but also grew up with the American Comic book
to reach a compromise and acceptance of both. I have always believed
that a graphic novel is a serious art form that is capable of dealing
with ideas that are as challenging and illustrative of serious ideas
as literature or as film.
Watchman
is a sequential art in a graphic book form. And covers autobiography,
art, journalism and history its also of considerable length and it
has to be read in order and not the way we might read a series of
comic strips..
The
story deals with the costumed heroes of our childhood. The sort of
superhero I can remember from seeing at my Grandfathers knee. Moore
and gibbons created a new set of Comic book Heroes based on the
characters we know and at the same time allowing a rich and varied
form of difference.
Nite
Owl has many of Batman characteristics, including a fascination with
gadgets and devices and almost a prototype Bat Cave. The Comedian,
who is killed in the first chapter but whose story is told in the
remembrances of other characters as the story unfolds. He is a sort
of dark Captain America. Silk SpecterI and II are a mother and
daughter from different generations of costumed heroes are more or
less Wonder Women even down to the costumes.
-brilliant
Ozymandius is a self made hero-brilliant, beautiful and strong a sort
of perceived Neitzchian Superman. He has developed his powers in such
way that he is now almost not human. He is roughly based on the Dc
Comics version of Marvel-man, an adapt ion of the earlier British
Miracle-man.. Then we have Rorschach the Vigilante who preys on the
fears of criminals but who operates almost completely outside the
bounds of society that he is pledged to protect.. His name comes from
the shifting shapes on the mask he wears. He is probably based on the
Charlton hero the ”he Question” Finally there is Dr Manhattan who
was damaged in a Nuclear accident he is a kind of mutation. He I is
the only hero with superpowers and he is very loosely based on the
traditional Superman of the films and comics .
Despite
their descent form these superheroes we see their charterers in a
unique way. They are darker as troubled as we are, more human and
dysfunctional both psychologically and sexually, they experience
problems of intimacy and search for an existential meaning outside of
their superhero selves. They are all at least middle aged and they
are all flawed in some way as we all are. To make them more
interesting these characters are place din a realistic world that
resembles our own and yet is different in a number of ways.
The
year of the watchman story is 1985. Richard Nixon is President and
there was no Watergate. Nixon has changed the Constitution to allow
himself to stay in power. Henry Kissinger is still Secretary of State
and because of Dr Manhattan his powers tipped the Cold War into an
American victory, largely because the Russians had nothing to
challenge him with.
In
1977 in this alternative world world the Police and Criminal
enforcement Agencies had grown frustrated with the costumed heroes
interference in their work and lives and went on strike. This caused
Congress to pass law against vigilantism. So most of these costumed
heroes have been retired some eight years.
The
Soviets and the Americans are in a massive arms race in the
alternative world. The expensive arms race has led to a declining
support for society's infrastructure, toads, buildings, transport and
services are constantly being curt back. Each side s are stockpiling
Nuclear war heads and the presence of Dr Manhattan has increased the
tension and there is a great fear that the Russians might try a
pre-emptive strike,
the
main plot of the novel concerns the the consequences of the murder of
the costumed hero the Comedian. The murder awakens in Rorschach the
suspicion that someone is trying to kill off the heroes and the ides
gains credence from other events, including a smear campaign against
Dr Manhattan that drives him into exile.. it becomes clear that there
is a conspiracy to eliminate the heroes and in particular Dr
Manhattan They suspect that the Soviets are behind it and this in
turn leads to a paranoia so frequent in such historical situations.
This paranoia has effect both collectively on society and the
individual psyches of the many players in the novel.
Most
of the sub-plots in the novel are based around ordinary people going
about their everyday lives experiencing the fear that a war is coming
that will wipe out all human life on Earth.. The real virtue of the
book is the detailed description of the lives of these minor
characters are overshadowed by the events of the larger plot.
There
is for example a graphic novel within the graphic novel.. it is
called “Marooned” that serves a variety of functions within
watchmen-allowing the news vendor and the boy who buys the graphic
novel to comment on the whole situation of the plot. This parallel
structure works throughout the novel. There are multiple plots, and
they are skilfully interweaves drawing our attention to contrast and
parallels in the main plot.
The
design and art in the book tie the many strands together. One of the
books unifying symbol;s is a smiley face, which appears in the cover
of the first issue. It turns out to be a button the Comedian wore
when he was thrown out of the high rise apartment window, and when
the body is taken away , the button remains in a pool of blood just
by a drain entrance. The button itself has one little drop of blood
across the right eye and this visage interweaves throughout the rest
of the book.
Another
feature of the book is the intercalary material. Between each chapter
is four pages of an essay or a collage of text material relating to
the them and background of the chapter or developing the storyline as
a whole. This material provides much of the texture for the book,
that provides information that enriches and deepens the book itself.
This material explores the motivation to become a superhero and
explores them in detail. It looks at reason far beyond the need to
create a just society and uses many ideas from the Jungian concept of
the shadow to even more complex psychoanalytical defence mechanisms.
The
book asks how far should we trust our guardians whether they are
middle aged superheroes coping with mid life crises or our own
government “protecting” us from external threats. It asks about
inter state and asks much about the nature of globalisation and
capitalism. We may also see within in questions about the nature of
bullying and power over others.. The point is that a society can see
itself as so invulnerable that it can do anything like stockpile
nuclear weapons and gloss over the reality of the true situation by
choosing to do what it wants.
The
book asks “Who watches the watchmen?” and provides no ultimate
answers. They watch each other watch themselves, the rest of the
world watches them and we as readers watch them too. The book reminds
us that the whole issue of superhero comics I sloaded witgh questions
about power and the way that power effects and changes us. The
graphic novel it provides is a worthy existential classic and reminds
us of Sartre claim that hell is other people.
Rorschach:
I heard joke once: Man goes to doctor. Says he's depressed. Life
seems harsh, and cruel. Says he feels all alone in threatening world.
Doctor says: "Treatment is simple. The great clown - Pagliacci -
is in town. Go see him. That should pick you up." Man bursts
into tears. "But doctor..." he says "I am Pagliacci."
Good joke. Everybody laugh. Roll on snare drum. Curtains.
Rorschach:
None of you seem to understand. I'm not locked in here with you.
You're locked in here with *ME*!
Adrian
Veidt:
I'm not a comic book villain. Do you seriously think I would explain
my master stroke to you if there were even the slightest possibility
you could affect the outcome? I triggered it 35 minutes ago.
Rorschach:
[reading
from journal]
Rorschach's Journal. October 12th, 1985: Dog carcass in alley this
morning, tire tread on burst stomach. This city is afraid of me. I
have seen its true face. The streets are extended gutters and the
gutters are full of blood and when the drains finally scab over, all
the vermin will drown. The accumulated filth of all their sex and
murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and
politicians will look up and shout "Save us!"... and I'll
whisper "no."
Rorschach:
You see, Doctor, God didn't kill that little girl. Fate didn't
butcher her and destiny didn't feed her to those dogs. If God saw
what any of us did that night he didn't seem to mind. From then on I
knew... God doesn't make the world this way. We do.
Rorschach:
Never compromise. Not even in the face of Armageddon. That's always
been the difference between us, Daniel.
Adrian
Veidt:
[Nixon
finishes his speech on Veidt's TVs]
Do you see? It's your super powers retreating from war. I've saved
the Earth from hell. We both have. This is as much your victory as
it is mine. Now we can return. Do what we were meant to.
Rorschach:
We were meant to exact justice! Everyone's gonna know what you've
done...
Adrian
Veidt:
Will they? By exposing me, you would sacrifice the peace so many
died for today.
Dan
Dreiberg:
Peace based on a lie.
Adrian
Veidt:
But peace! Nonetheless.
Jon
Osterman:
...He's right. Exposing Adrian would only doom the world to Nuclear
destruction again.
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
No... we can't do this.
Jon
Osterman:
On Mars, you taught me the value of life. If we hope to preserve it
here, we must remain silent.
Rorschach:
Keep your own secrets...
[the
others look as Rorscach leaves, then Jon and Adrian make eye
contact]
Dan
Dreiberg:
Don't even think about it.
[Goes
after Rorscach]
Dan
Dreiberg:
Rorscach! Wait.
Rorschach:
[Turns]
Never compromise. Not even in the face of Armageddon. That's always
been the difference between us, Daniel.
[Leaves
the building]
Adrian
Veidt:
I've made myself feel every death... see every innocent face I've
murdered to save humanity.
[Turns
to Jon]
Adrian
Veidt:
You understand, don't you?
Jon
Osterman:
Without condoning... or condemning. I understand.
Rorschach:
[Outside,
in the snow, Rorscach comes across a copy of Jon standing in the
snow]
Out of my way. People have to be told.
Jon
Osterman:
You know I can't let you do that.
Rorschach:
Suddenly you discover humanity. Convenient.
[Takes
off his mask]
Rorschach:
If you'd cared from the start, none of this would've happened.
Jon
Osterman:
I can change almost anything... but I can't change human nature.
Rorschach:
Of course, you must protect Veidt's new Utopia. One more body
amongst foundations makes little difference. Well, what are you
waiting for? Do it...
[Jon
hesitates]
Rorschach:
DO IT!
[Jon
makes Rorscach explode into a pile of blood]
Dan
Dreiberg:
NOOOOOOOO!
Dr.
Manhattan:
She was pregnant. And you gunned her down.
Edward
Blake:
That's right. And you know what, you watched me. You could've turned
the gun into steam, the bullets into mercury, the bottle into
goddamned snowflakes but you didn't, did you? You really don't give
a damn about human beings. You're driftin' out of touch, Doc. God
help us all.
[after
killing a murderer who begged to be arrested]
Rorschach:
Men get arrested. Dogs get put down.
Rorschach:
Rorschach's Journal: October 12th, 1985. Tonight, a comedian died in
New York.
:
It doesn't take a genius to see that the world has problems.Adrian
Veidt
Edward
Blake:
No, but it takes a room full of morons to think they're small enough
for you to handle.
Rorschach:
Give me back my face!
Edward
Blake:
Once you realize what a joke everything is, being the Comedian is
the only thing that makes sense.
Jon
Osterman:
Reassembling myself was the first trick I learned. It didn't kill
Osterman... did you really think it would kill me? I have walked
across the surface of the Sun. I have witnessed events so tiny and
so fast they can hardly be said to have occurred at all. But you,
Adrian, you're just a man. The world's smartest man poses no more
threat to me than does its smartest termite.
Dan
Dreiberg:
What happened to us? What happened to the American Dream?
:
"What happened to the American Dream?" It came true!
You're lookin' at it...
Edgar
Jacobi:
I have cancer.
Rorschach:
What kind of cancer?
Edgar
Jacobi:
Well, you know the kind you eventually get better from?
Rorschach:
Yes.
Edgar
Jacobi:
Well, that ain't the kind I got.
Jon
Osterman:
In my opinion, the existence of life is a highly overrated
phenomenon.
Jon
Osterman:
Will you smile? If I admit I was wrong?
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
About what?
Jon
Osterman:
Miracles. Events with astronomical odds of occurring, like oxygen
turning into gold. I've longed to witness such an event, and yet I
neglect that in human coupling, millions upon millions of cells
compete to create life, for generation after generation until,
finally, your mother loves a man, Edward Blake, the Comedian, a man
she has every reason to hate, and out of that contradiction, against
unfathomable odds, it's you - only you - that emerged. To distill so
specific a form, from all that chaos. It's like turning air into
gold. A miracle. And so... I was wrong. Now dry your eyes, and let's
go home.
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
The most powerful thing in the universe... still just a puppet.
Jon
Osterman:
We are all puppets, Laurie. I'm just the puppet who can see the
strings.
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
Do you remember that crazy guy? What did he call himself... Captain
Carnage. The one who used to pretend he was a supervillain just so
he could get beaten up all the time?
Dan
Dreiberg:
Yeah, he tried that on me once. I just walked away. He starts
following me down the street in broad daylight, yelling 'Punish me!
Punish me!' I'm just saying 'No! Get lost.'
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
God. Whatever happened to him?
Dan
Dreiberg:
Well, he pulled that on Rorschach, and Rorschach dropped him down an
elevator shaft.
[pause,
then both laugh]
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
Oh my god. That isn't even funny.
Jon
Osterman:
I am looking at the stars. They are so far away, and their light
takes so long to reach us. All we ever see of stars is their old
photographs.
Rorschach:
[voiceover]
Rorschach's journal, October 13th, 1985. 8:30 PM. Meeting with
Dreiberg left bad taste in mouth. A flabby failure who sits
whimpering in his basement. Why are so few of us left active,
healthy, and without personality disorders? The first Nite Owl runs
an auto repair shop. The first Silk Spectre is a bloated, aging
whore, dying in a California rest resort. Dollar Bill got his cape
stuck in a revolving door where he got gunned down. Silhouette,
murdered: a victim of her own indecent lifestyle. Mothman's in an
asylum in Maine. Only two names remain on my list. Both share
private quarters at Rockefeller Military Research Center. I shall go
to them. I shall go tell the indestructible man that someone plans
to murder him.
Adrian
Veidt:
I don't mind being the smartest man in the world, I just wish it
wasn't this one.
Rorschach:
Of course. You must protect Veidt's new utopia. What's one more body
amongst the foundations? Well, what are you waiting for? Do it.
[Dr.
Manhattan hesitates]
Rorschach:
DO IT!
Dr.
Manhattan:
I feel fear, for the last time.
Rorschach:
We need to squeeze people.
Rorschach:
You forgot how we do things, Daniel. You've gotten too soft. Too
trusting. Especially with women.
Dan
Dreiberg:
No, listen, I am through with that! God, who do you think you are,
Rorschach? You live off people while insulting them and nobody
complains because they think you're a goddamn lunatic!
Dan
Dreiberg:
[Rorschach
approaches Dan, who sighs and turns to him]
I'm sorry. I shouldn't have said that, man.
Rorschach:
Daniel? You are a good friend.
[extends
his hand and Dan takes it]
Detective
Fine:
[From
outside Moloch's apartment]
Rorschach! This is the police, we know you're in there.
Rorschach:
No! No!
Detective
Fine:
[From
outside Moloch's apartment]
If there's anybody in there with you, send 'em out unharmed.
Rorschach:
No! No, no, no, no!
Rorschach:
Walked right into it! Stupid, stupid, stupid! Never surrender.
Rorschach:
When you are.
Jon
Osterman:
What is this? Another ultimate weapon?
Adrian
Veidt:
Yes. You could say that.
[Veidt
turns on TVs with remote]
Sally
Jupiter:
I'm 67 years old. Every day, the future looks a little bit darker.
But the past... even the grimy parts of it... keep on getting
brighter.
[Laurie
and Dan are breaking Rorschach out of prison]
Rorschach:
Need to visit men's room.
Laurie
Juspeczyk:
Oh, Christ!
Dan
Dreiberg:
I'm not the one still hiding behind a mask.
Rorschach:
No. You're hiding in plain sight.
Dr.
Manhattan:
They claim their labors are to build a heaven, yet their heaven is
populated by horrors. Perhaps the world is not made. Perhaps nothing
is made. A clock without a craftsman. It's too late. Always has
been, always will be. Too late.
Wally
Weaver:
You see, at the time I was misquoted. I never said 'The Super-man
exists and he is American', what I said was '*God* exists and he is
American'. Now if you begin to feel an intense and crushing feeling
of religious terror at the concept, don't be alarmed. That indicates
only that you are still sane.
Sally
Jupiter:
Things are tough all over, cupcake. It rains on the just and unjust
alike. The Comedian was a little bit of both.
Adrian
Veidt:
Dan. A world united in peace... there had to be sacrifice.
Dan
Dreiberg:
No! You haven't idealized mankind but you've... you've deformed it!
You mutilated it. That's your legacy. That's the real practical
joke.
Sally
Jupiter:
[Eddie
is aggressively coming on to Sally despite her reluctance]
I said "no", Eddie.
Sally
Jupiter:
"No" spelled N-O. All right?
Rorschach:
This city's afraid of me... I've seen its true face...
Edward
Blake:
God damn I love working on American soil, Dan. Ain't had this much
fun since Woodward and Bernstein.
Dan
Dreiberg:
How long can we keep this up?
Edward
Blake:
Congress is pushing through some new bill that's gonna outlaw masks.
Our days are numbered. Till then it's like you always say, we're
society's only protection.
Dan
Dreiberg:
From what?
Edward
Blake:
You kidding me? From themselves.
Dan
Dreiberg:
[referring
to the exit tunnel]
There's a maintenance hatch that will let you out two blocks north.
Rorschach:
I remember. I used to come here often, back when we were partners.
Dan
Dreiberg:
Those were good times, huh Rorschach? What happened?
Rorschach:
I don't like you.
Prison
Psychiatrist:
Ah. You don't like me? Well, why is that?
Rorschach:
Because you're fat.
Janet
Black:
Doctor Manhattan as you know the Doomsday Clock is a symbolic clock
face analogizing humankind's proximity to extinction, midnight
representing the threat of nuclear war. As of now it stands at four
minutes to midnight. Would you agree that we are that close to
annihilation?
Jon
Osterman:
My father was a watch maker. He abandoned it when Einstein
discovered time is relative. I would only agree that a symbolic
clock is as nourishing to the intellect as photograph of oxygen to a
drowning man.
[Looking
at psychiatrist's ink blot, remembering being bullied]
Rorschach:
Clouds.
Adrian
Veidt:
The only person with whom I felt any kinship with died three hundred
years before the birth of Christ. Alexander of Macedonia, or
Alexander the Great, as
No comments:
Post a Comment